Seven Doors Out of the Cap: Auditing the Exceptions That Redefine Your Liability Limit
Photo: John Owens (talk), CC BY 2.5, via Wikimedia Commons
There is a moment in every negotiation when the number is agreed. Twelve months of turnover, the value of the contract, the insurance limit, or a round figure produced by the finance director. It goes into the clause. The parties move on to something else. Everyone behaves as though the risk allocation is settled.
It is not. The cap is a headline, and beneath it sits a list of exceptions, each of which removes a category of liability from its protection. Read the exceptions before you read the number, because the exceptions describe the risk that will actually be transferred. What follows is not a template but a reading discipline: seven doors out of the cap, and what each one costs.
1. Fraud and Fraudulent Misrepresentation
No cap survives fraud, and no drafter should try to make one. The difficulty is definitional. A carve-out for fraud is read narrowly, and a carve-out for dishonesty, wilful misconduct or deliberate breach may be read more broadly than the supplier intended. The question for the customer is whether the carve-out reaches the conduct it actually fears: a representation known to be untrue when made, or a deliberate concealment during performance. The question for the supplier is whether the wording has quietly become an all-purpose exception, defeating the cap on any allegation of bad faith.
2. Death or Personal Injury
Section 2(1) of the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 prevents a business from excluding or restricting liability for death or personal injury resulting from negligence. The carve-out is therefore compulsory, and its presence tells you nothing about the commercial bargain. Its scope, however, does. A clause that excludes the cap for death or personal injury simpliciter may extend further than the statute requires, catching injury that owes nothing to negligence. Precision here is free, and the absence of it is not.
3. Intellectual Property Infringement
IP indemnities are habitually carved out of the cap, sometimes with their own super-cap, sometimes without any limit at all. The commercial logic is understandable: infringement exposure is hard to quantify and may be catastrophic. The legal effect is that the largest uncapped exposure in the contract is often the one the supplier has least ability to price. Customers should ask whether the indemnity is uncapped and uninsured; suppliers should ask whether their own modifications and combinations are excluded from the indemnity, as they should be.
4. Confidentiality
A confidentiality carve-out is standard and usually uncapped. The risk is not the principle but the trigger. Where the obligation is drafted broadly, extending to any information disclosed in the course of the relationship, and the carve-out is triggered by any breach, the cap may be displaced by an incident of modest consequence. A short, specific list of what confidentiality really protects, and a defined category of sensitive information, keeps the exception proportionate to the risk it addresses.
5. Data Protection
Data protection carve-outs have become the least examined clause in the contract. A well-drafted provision distinguishes between regulatory action against a party, third-party claims by data subjects, and the cost of notification and remediation. The distinctions matter because the exposures are different in kind. A regulatory fine is a public penalty; whether it can be passed between commercial parties is a question of public policy as much as of drafting, and an indemnity for one's own fine may be unenforceable or uninsurable. Third-party claims are the more sensible subject of an indemnity, and the one most often overlooked.
6. Payment Obligations
A liability cap is a limit on damages. It does not limit a debt. Where the contract carves out sums due, or treats the payment of invoices as outside the cap, the customer retains an unlimited obligation to pay and the supplier retains an unlimited claim for non-payment, together with interest and any agreed recovery costs. This is rarely a drafting error, but it is often a misunderstanding: finance teams frequently assume the cap protects the whole of the cash exposure, and it does not.
7. Regulatory Fines and Penalties
An indemnity for regulatory penalties transfers the consequence of a public enforcement decision to a private party. Beyond the enforceability question, the carve-out creates a practical hazard: it places the entire penalty outside the cap while the underlying conduct remains within the supplier's control. Where such a carve-out is unavoidable, the sensible structure is a separate, defined limit for regulatory exposure, a rollover of that limit into the aggregate cap, and a cooperation obligation that gives the customer a role in the defence.
The Lesser Doors
Three further exceptions deserve the same treatment. Gross negligence, where it is defined at all, is an exception of unlimited reach and imprecise meaning. The failure to maintain insurance is sometimes carved out, which converts an administrative lapse into an uncapped liability. And the interaction of an indemnity with the general cap is frequently left unresolved, producing an argument about whether indemnity claims sit inside the aggregate figure or alongside it.
How to Audit a Cap in an Afternoon
- Read clause by clause and list every carve-out, in the order in which it appears.
- For each, identify what has actually been removed from the cap: a liability, a category of claim, or a remedy.
- Identify whether the carve-out is subject to any separate limit, and whether that limit rolls into the aggregate.
- Check the trigger wording. A carve-out triggered by any breach will be relied on far more often than one triggered by a defined event.
- Map each carve-out to the insurance programme. Anything uninsured and uncapped is a balance-sheet exposure, whoever has agreed to it.
- Test each carve-out against the counterparty's ability to pay. An uncapped indemnity from a thinly capitalised entity allocates risk on paper only.
- Reconcile the whole with the exclusion of consequential loss and the definition of loss, since a carve-out is meaningless where the loss itself is not recoverable.
A liability cap is a statement about the shape of the risk the parties are willing to share. The exceptions are the statement about the risk they are not. Read together, they describe the contract. Read separately, the cap is a number that has already left the room.