Valenstein & Fatt All articles
Employment & Liability

The Payroll Behind the Service: Contracting for Staff When an Outsourcing Changes Hands

Valenstein & Fatt
The Payroll Behind the Service: Contracting for Staff When an Outsourcing Changes Hands

Photo: office handover meeting employees documentation transfer UK business, via hjkreasindo.com

The contract said that TUPE may apply and that each party would comply with its obligations under it. On the first morning of the new service, a hundred and forty staff reported to a customer who had budgeted for a technology migration, two pension arrangements that nobody had reconciled, and a recognised union that had not been consulted. The clause had been accurate. It had simply not been useful.

Transfers of staff in outsourcing, re-tendering and insourcing are governed by the Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations 2006. The Regulations do most of the work automatically. The contract cannot disapply them; it can only allocate the cost of getting them wrong. That is a narrower function than most TUPE schedules assume, and a more valuable one if performed properly.

The Transfer Test Is Factual, Not Contractual

A service provision change arises where a client engages a contractor to carry out activities on its behalf, where a contractor is replaced by a subsequent contractor, or where activities are brought back in-house. The test requires an organised grouping of resources with the principal purpose of carrying out the activities, and the activities must not be in connection with a single specific event or task of short duration.

The grouping is assessed in practice, not on the face of the contract. A supplier that staffs a service from a shared pool, with no team dedicated to the client, may argue that no grouping exists; a client that has described the service as a discrete, dedicated function in its own tender documents will find that argument harder to run. Drafters should assume that the description of the service in the specification will be read as a description of the grouping.

Employee Liability Information: The Twenty-Eight Day Clock

Regulation 11 requires the transferor to provide specified employee liability information to the transferee at least twenty-eight days before the transfer. The particulars are prescribed: identity and age, the written particulars of employment, information about disciplinary and grievance procedures in the previous two years, and information about claims brought against the transferor in the previous two years together with their outcome.

A transferor that fails to comply is exposed to compensation under regulation 12, subject to a minimum award of five hundred pounds per employee. That figure is a floor, not a tariff, and tribunals have shown themselves willing to award more where the failure has left a transferee negotiating blind. Contractually, the obligation should be supported by a warranty of accuracy rather than of provision, a right to request updates, and an indemnity for the consequences of inaccuracy rather than mere non-delivery.

Indemnities: Who Pays, and Who Can Actually Pay

The conventional allocation is familiar. The transferor indemnifies the transferee against liabilities arising from acts or omissions before the transfer; the transferee indemnifies the transferor against liabilities arising after it. The convention is sound. The execution often is not.

Three questions are usually left unanswered. First, what counts as a pre-transfer liability: a claim presented after completion but arising from a pre-completion act is within the indemnity in principle, but the drafting must say so, and must address the position where the claim spans the transfer date. Second, how long the indemnity survives, given that employment claims may be presented months after the event. Third, and most often overlooked, whether the indemnifying party will still exist when the claim arrives.

An indemnity from a special purpose vehicle with no assets behind it is a promise, not a security. A parent guarantee, a retention, or an insurance-backed arrangement converts it into something a finance director can recognise.

Pensions: The Gap Between Regulation 10 and the Board's Assumption

Regulation 10 excludes occupational pension schemes from transferring, save for limited rights relating to old age, invalidity and survivors' benefits. Boards frequently read this as meaning pensions are not a TUPE issue. Operationally the opposite is true: the exclusion creates a two-tier workforce, an equal treatment argument, and, in public sector engagements, the expectations of the Fair Deal policy, under which transferring staff are offered a broadly comparable scheme.

The contract should record which scheme applies to which cohort, who administers it, who bears the cost of any admitted body status or bond, and what happens on a subsequent transfer. Where a broadly comparable scheme is promised, the mechanism for demonstrating comparability should be fixed at the outset rather than discovered at the first actuarial review.

Harmonisation: What Regulation 4 Will and Will Not Permit

Regulation 4 provides that a transfer does not terminate the contract of employment and that any purported variation is void where the sole or principal reason is the transfer. The prohibition is not absolute. A variation is permitted where the sole or principal reason is an economic, technical or organisational reason entailing changes in the workforce, and the static construction of the Regulations, which has generally prevailed in the tribunals, means that the terms transfer as they stand on the transfer date and do not improve automatically thereafter.

The practical consequence is that harmonisation is a project, not a clause. It needs a timetable, a consultation process and, in most cases, the consent of the affected employees or their representatives. A contract that provides for harmonisation without providing for any of those things has simply moved the dispute from the commercial relationship to the employment tribunal.

The Second-Generation Problem

The transfer that ends a contract is often the one nobody drafted for. Where a supplier loses a service to a competitor, the information and cooperation it must provide is the difference between a clean handover and an industrial dispute. The change-of-provider clause should require the outgoing supplier to provide employee data in a specified form at a specified date, to cooperate with consultation, and to refrain from any step designed to destabilise the incoming provider.

It should also address the data protection position. Employee data transferred under the Regulations is processed on a statutory footing, but the practical arrangements for transfer, retention and deletion still need to be documented, and the client, which frequently sits between two suppliers, is usually the party holding the information.

A Drafting Checklist

  1. Describe the service so that the grouping is evident, and allocate responsibility for identifying transferring staff.
  2. Specify the employee liability information timetable, with a warranty of accuracy and an indemnity for inaccuracy.
  3. Align the indemnity period with the limitation periods for the claims it covers.
  4. Require security for indemnity obligations where the counterparty is thinly capitalised.
  5. Map pensions cohort by cohort, including admitted body status and bond costs.
  6. Set out the harmonisation mechanism, including consultation, rather than the harmonisation outcome.
  7. Provide for a second-generation transfer: data, cooperation, timing and confidentiality.
  8. Address consultation obligations and the cost of a protective award.
  9. Confirm who bears the cost of any failure to inform and consult, and whether that liability is shared.
  10. Review the clause at each service change, not only at signature.

A TUPE schedule is not a disclaimer. It is an operating manual for the day the service changes hands, and it should be written for the person who will be standing in the room when it does.

All Articles

Related Articles

Silence Has Limits: Drafting Confidentiality Clauses Around Protected Disclosures in 2026

Silence Has Limits: Drafting Confidentiality Clauses Around Protected Disclosures in 2026

Mistletoe, Indemnities and Incident Logs: Contracting for the 2026 Office Christmas Party

Mistletoe, Indemnities and Incident Logs: Contracting for the 2026 Office Christmas Party

Vesting Is Not Delivery: What a Customer Actually Acquires in a Commissioned Deliverable

Vesting Is Not Delivery: What a Customer Actually Acquires in a Commissioned Deliverable